Last year we had a small dinner with close family, so I wanted something simple, inexpensive and easy to achieve.
I bought shipping paper, stencils and a large chalk pen at AC Moore and drew my own tablecloth. For the tablescape, I bought a roll of wide burlap, two pumpkins (spray painted them gold and then used glitter spray paint) and used little plastic apples for the plates. All of these items were purchased at AC Moore and came out great!
(I apologize for the quality of the pictures as these were taken with my cell phone.)